It is used on joyous and holy occasions, but can have devastating effects when used inappropriately. To learn more or opt-out, read our Cookie Policy. The apple’s many admirers like to portray it as a symbol of wholesomeness – apple cheeks, an apple for teacher, and so forth. Despite their central role in the story, the Tree and its fruit are never identified in the text. The response given is that in the Garden of Eden, wheat stalks resembled pillars as tall as cedars in Lebanon. As you suggest, the original Hebrew says only “fruit,” but in latter-day Western art ranging from serious religious painting to about a million cartoons, the item in question is invariably depicted as an apple. Did Chava actually produce bread? 7. Noah’s Flood: a Historical, Global Catastrophe, Considering that Adam and Eve were preprogrammed with language and knowledge so that they could immediately converse with God, they may have known right from the start that the fruit was edible. 8. Take your pick: In any event, the gist is clear: knowledge = the loss of innocence; ignorance = bliss. The word in Genesis 2:17 for evil is rah, while the word for apples in Proverbs 25:11 and Song of Solomon 2:3 is tappuwach. Did Chava actually produce bread? The most famous apple of Greek myth is the one you cite, the gold apple labeled “To the fairest” that Eris, goddess of discord, throws among the guests at a wedding party, leading to the judgment of Paris (he has to choose whether Hera, Aphrodite, or Athena is the most beautiful) and ultimately to the Trojan War. The obvious question is, how did this idea come about? apart from altierder who I belive is christan because of the fact he could hold and control the apple due to the fact the fall(adem and eve) was christian so I think the reson that the Templar's wanted it is because they wanted to destroy the thing that god said would give all bad knowledge of man kind to please him. A late custom developed (Elef Hamagen, in the back of Mateh Efraim 660:6) that on Hoshanah Rabbah pregnant women break off the pitum from the etrog and recite a prayer for their and their child’s well-being that centers on Chava’s sin. An alternative answer provided is that the word “, ” in the Bible can refer to either tree or wood, and thus, in this context, it could have meant “wood,” referring to the stalk of the wheat. in Latin) were words that denoted a generic fruit or a round object. Today, whether in art or popular culture, the Forbidden Fruit is most often depicted as the apple. The word evil in the tree's name in Latin is mali (Genesis 2:17). ©2020 Orthodox Union. Would love your thoughts, please comment. In Italian the tomato is pomodoro, from “apple of gold,” and in French it was called “pomme d’amour,” leading to the colloquial “love apple” and the Hebrew agvania, which alludes to courtship. Well, it was never described as an "apple". 16. See Miklos Faust, “The Apple in Paradise,” HortTechnology 4 (Oct/Dec 1994), 338-343. It seems like this similarity may have led to the confusion. That did not stop subsequent generations, including the rabbinic Sages, from trying to identify the Forbidden Fruit. If a vampire bites a horse would that create a horse vampire? In older art, the Forbidden Fruit is often a non-descript fruit. This is odd, as the sabra originated in Mexico and made its way to the Middle East in the sixteenth century. When was the last time you were a great mechanic? In the Vulgate—the Latin translation of the Bible— “the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil” in Bereishit 2:17 is called “, (pronounced mah-lum), meaning evil. It has been suggested that starting in the twelfth to thirteenth century, richer, larger apples began replacing the small apples used for cider in northern Europe and lush apple orchards were planted by monks, setting the stage for this now common and popular apple to be the central fruit in paradise. 19. Eden is only a mythological place that did not actually exist. Known in Spanish as “, —Adam’s fig—the sabra was associated with the fruit of the Garden of Eden. As all were too preoccupied by the war to see any other threat, a major solar flare impacted the Earth, and significantly damaged both mankind and their makers. The response given is that in the Garden of Eden, wheat stalks resembled pillars as tall as cedars in Lebanon. From there, it made its way into other translations. An Adam’s apple, the laryngeal prominence on the human neck (mostly found on males) is named either because it looks as if a piece of the apple got lodged there or, more likely, because it is a round bulge. From there, it made its way into other translations. While more common in Christian art, it can be found in Jewish sources as well. Therefore, one may assume that the fruit would be impossible to eat (inedible). 2:2) calls the large pile of ashes in the center of the altar “, ” and the Rosh explains that anything gathered together and piled high is called, The pile of grapes in a wine press is referred to as a, 20) and the gold and silver round bells on a, to refer to “fruit.” In other languages the word apple is used to refer to generic fruit or round objects. Genesis depicts Adam and Eve leading the plush life in Eden. apple of eden … The story of Gan Eden has a message irrespective of the fruit’s identity: Man was given a blessed life but needed to adhere to certain boundaries and restrictions; he failed and paid the price. Vayikra Rabbah 12:1) states that Chava squeezed the grapes and they drank the wine. Fact: The fruit’s identity is not revealed in the Biblical text, and while early Jewish sources offer a variety of suggestions about which fruit Chava fed Adam, an apple is not one of them. Of course, there may have been a bit more deception than this. The Targum translates tapuach as etrog (Shir Hashirim 2:3) and as tapuah deginta dieden—the apple of the Garden of Eden (ibid., 2:5, 7:9). Early Christian scholars often took the forbidden fruit to be an apple, possibly because of the irresistible pun suggested by the Latin malum, which means both “apple” and “evil.” At least one early Latin translation of the bible uses “apple” instead of “fruit.” A contributing factor no doubt was that apples were a lot more popular in Europe than in the Middle East, where it’s generally too hot for them to thrive. An alternative answer provided is that the word “eitz” in the Bible can refer to either tree or wood, and thus, in this context, it could have meant “wood,” referring to the stalk of the wheat. One of the most unusual suggestions made is that the Forbidden Fruit is the sabra. Eating the Forbidden Fruit brought death with its accompanying wailing and bitterness to the world, perhaps indicating that wine was the culprit. It says that she saw that the fruit was good for food. Religion has nothing to do with it, and their names are "Ezio Auditore" and "Altaïr". Ramban points the reader to the Targumim on Bereishit 2:9, Shemot 20:14 (or Devarim 5:18), and Tehillim 45:14. Wheat is not usually eaten raw. He said ‘See my son’s fragrance is like the smell of the field blessed by God’” (Bereishit 27:27). Identifying the Tree of Knowledge with the banana appears to be a Christian tradition from at least the twelfth century that enjoyed popularity but was never adopted by rabbinic sources.